8 Hill Street St Helier Jersey JE2 4UA

Print This Post Print This Post

Employee sues firm for wishing her a happy birthday and sending her a birthday card

Employment Law | Jersey Business Legal Services

A recent case in the UK employment tribunal highlights that hurt feelings do not always equate to a valid claim under employment law.  Jersey Employment law is likely to follow the same principle.

According to the judgment, the employee, claimed she was ‘utterly shocked’ when a fellow employee ‘jumped at her like a snake’ to ask about her birthday. Her colleague reportedly said: ‘It was your 50th wasn’t it, you can’t hide it you know’.

The upset employee left the office early, saying she was so upset by the incident that she ‘would not be able to concentrate further that afternoon’. In a letter to the firm, she said she had felt ‘ambushed, punched, slapped and humiliated’ by the ‘unsolicited’ comments. She added: ‘I come to work to earn money. Even so, I try to be friendly, polite and sociable. However, I’m a private person with a belief that personal matters can remain private and should do so if the individual wishes it.’

Staff at the firm had also sent the upset employee a birthday card in the post, in line with the office’s practice to mark each other’s birthdays.

Tribunal Decision

The tribunal found inter alia that the upset employee‘s sensitivity about her age appeared ‘unusual and extreme’ and there was not sufficient evidence to show that other members of staff who were over 50 would have been treated differently. It added that the comment was ‘trivial and had not been delivered maliciously’ and ‘the birthday card was intended for the claimant as an act of kindness’.

Parslows Jersey can help

We are experts in all aspects of Jersey employment law, including employment contracts and policies, redundancies, disciplinary, capability and grievance procedures, discrimination, compromise agreements and tribunal representation.

Our lawyers have a proven track record providing advice and representation on a wide range of employment law and HR issues. We have the experience and knowledge you need, whether advising on a contract or representing you in an employment tribunal. We’re committed to helping you get the best outcome possible.

For further information please do not hesitate to call 630530 or email us on  employmentlawyers@parslowsjersey.com

Please note that the information provided on this website is for general information purposes only and is designed to provide you with an outline of the legal services we offer.  Whilst we endeavour to ensure our information is correct and useful, we make no representations or warranties regarding the accuracy or completeness of the information offered.  Information on our website does not constitute legal advice and Parslows Jersey accepts no liability for any loss or damage arising out of, or in connection with, the information found in this website.  Please consult a lawyer at Parslows Jersey in the event that you require professional assurance that our information, and your interpretation of the same, is correct.


Parslows Jersey are here to help with all your legal queries call us today on +44 (0) 1534 630530

Or email us on enquiries@parslowsjersey.com